The intuition to retire: buyers choose their brand each time, so better arguments and better ads win them over. The reality: for frequent purchases, the choice happened once (maybe years ago, maybe by inheriting a parent's brand) and what happens now is repetition. Habits run on a simple loop: a cue (morning, the shelf, the app icon, an empty jar) triggers a routine (buy the usual) which delivers an expected reward (the familiar taste, the job done), and every completed lap wires the loop a little tighter. Attitudes, arguments, and even mild dissatisfaction sit outside the loop. The cue doesn't consult them.
This is why so much "loyalty" dissolves under inspection. Ehrenberg's repeat-buying research found the unromantic truth: most buyers of any brand are light buyers who also buy rivals, and their repeat behaviour follows statistical regularities that look nothing like devotion. Much of what CRM decks call love is actually inertia: a routine nobody has had a reason to re-examine. That's not bad news. A routine is more durable than a preference. But it must be defended as a routine: by availability, consistency, and cue ownership, not by assuming affection will survive a stockout.
Habits do break — just not when ads ask them to. They loosen when context changes, because the cue disappears: moving cities, a new job, marriage, a first child, even a renovated supermarket. Researchers call it the habit-discontinuity effect, and it's the attacker's whole playbook. A buyer who has repurchased the same brand two hundred times will re-decide in the week their world rearranges, which is why brands fight for students, new parents, and new movers with an intensity that looks irrational until you see what's actually for sale: a slot in the next decade's routine.
One aisle can show you both sides of the war. Colgate's red pack owns the Indian morning so deeply that "Colgate" doubles as a word for toothpaste, the loop running at civilisational scale. Sensodyne, sitting a shelf away, cannot out-habit that, so it doesn't try. It recruits dentists (an authority with standing to interrupt the routine) and a moment of pain (sensitivity) that forces one deliberate look at the category. Habit versus habit-breaker: the same aisle, two entirely different physics.