Put the stated reason and the real reason side by side, because the gap between them is this entire topic. Stated: "I buy this tea for the taste, and it's reasonably priced." Real: this brand of tea has meant family, warmth, and belonging in a thousand advertisements across decades, and the pack on the shelf triggers a feeling its rivals don't. Stated: "This laptop had the best specs for the price." Real: the shortlist only ever contained brands the buyer would be comfortable opening in a meeting. The function justifies; the feeling decides.
The stack has four working layers. Functional: the job the product objectively does (tea refreshes, a bike commutes, a card pays). Emotional: the feeling the purchase produces or protects (comfort, excitement, relief from a nagging anxiety). Social: what the choice signals to others (taste, status, tribe). Identity: what the choice confirms to the buyer about themselves ("I'm the kind of person who..."). The layers aren't alternatives. A single purchase runs several at once, and categories differ mainly in which layer does the deciding. Salt is nearly all function. A wedding sherwani is nearly all social and identity. Most brands live in between and misjudge where.
Why can't buyers just tell you? Two honest reasons. First, much of motivation is genuinely non-conscious. Emotional responses fire before verbal reasoning gets involved, and the neuroscience is blunt about it: patients with damaged emotional circuitry don't become perfectly rational shoppers, they become unable to decide at all. Feeling isn't the enemy of deciding. It's the mechanism. Second, answering a researcher is itself a social performance: "I bought it for my kids' nutrition" is a better story to tell a stranger than "the ad made me feel like a good mother, and I need that feeling." Both answers are about the same purchase. Only one shows up in your survey.
None of this makes function optional. The product must do the job, and in genuinely functional moments (the medicine aisle, the emergency plumber) function leads. The mistake to retire is the assumption that your category is one of those moments. It usually isn't: in most markets, competing products all do the job, which is precisely why the deciding vote moves up the stack.