The conflicts are structural, not accidental, because each P has a natural owner optimising locally: product management wants more spec, finance wants more margin, sales wants more channel, marketing wants more noise. Left unrefereed, the mix ships as a negotiation nobody finished: a premium product in a discount channel with schizophrenic advertising. The truth-teller is pocket margin by channel: compute what the company actually keeps per unit in each route to market, and most mix 'mysteries' become arithmetic.
Porter's trade-off logic is the referee. Strategy is as much what you refuse as what you do, because refusals are what competitors can't copy without dismantling themselves. A lead lever only defends you when the other Ps are configured to serve it. Everyday low prices are safe from imitation precisely because matching them requires a rival to rebuild its stores, assortment, and cost culture, not just reprint tags. A mix where every lever is 'optimised' independently has no such lock: it's four best practices adding up to no strategy.
The promotion↔price conflict deserves its own physics because it compounds. Every discount teaches two audiences: buyers learn the real price is the promo price and start timing purchases, and the trade learns to stop ordering at list and wait for schemes. Reference prices ratchet downward and rebuilding them costs years. The discipline is guardrails set in advance (depth caps, frequency logic, a reason attached to every cut like festival or stock clearance) so promotion spends equity knowingly instead of leaking it.
Place↔place is the modern flashpoint: D2C economics look irresistible per unit until the trade, still moving most of the volume, retaliates with lost shelf priority. The workable answers are structural, not diplomatic: differentiated packs and SKUs per channel so prices never face each other directly, launch exclusives that give each channel something to win with, and honest maths about which channel is being used for margin and which for reach. Channel conflict solved after launch is twice as expensive as channel design done before it.