Value is subjective, comparative, and situational, and it helps to take those one at a time. Subjective: the same glass of lassi is worth far more on a June afternoon in Delhi than on a cool January morning. Comparative: buyers never judge you in a vacuum. It's always against the next-best option, which might be a competitor, a workaround, or simply doing nothing. Situational: that set of options shifts with the occasion, which is why the same person happily pays ₹40 for water inside a cinema when they'd never pay it at a kirana.
The cost side of the equation is where amateurs under-count. Price is only the visible cost. The full bill also includes time (finding it, learning it, waiting for it), effort (setup, maintenance), risk (what if it fails? what will people think?), and switching pain (the data, habits, and relationships you leave behind). Plenty of products lose not because they're overpriced, but because they're over-costed on some dimension nobody at the company ever measures.
A value proposition is a choice, not a description, and its power comes from what it leaves out. 'Quality products at great prices with excellent service' isn't a proposition at all. It's a refusal to choose. IndiGo doesn't promise you lounge luxury. DMart doesn't promise you ambience. The promises you exclude are what fund the ones you keep, and that trade is the whole strategy.
And a value proposition has to be provable, not just claimable. Every promise you make triggers an audit in the buyer's mind: 'on time' gets checked against your last delay, 'pure' against a karat-meter, 'lowest prices' against a single search. The promise and its proof are really one design problem. A claim with no visible way to check it is just ad copy waiting to be caught out.